You Just Never Know When the Holy Spirit Is Involved

From a nearly missed stop on the National Eucharistic Pilgrimage to St. Patrick’s Cathedral, an unexpected encounter reveals the quiet way grace moves ahead of history.

I had no idea that one day he’d become the Archbishop of New York.

But then again, how could I have known? Why would I?

Years ago, I photographed a cardinal just as he stepped into the Sistine Chapel.

He became Pope.

And last year I did the same…without credentials, mind you.

Don’t get me wrong, credentials matter…until they don’t.

Only later did history catch up to those moments.

All this to say it’s happened more than once.

Which is perhaps the point.

When the Holy Spirit is involved, you never really know who you’re standing in front of, or why you were led there in the first place.

I was reminded of that truth again last year while covering the kickoff of the National Eucharistic Pilgrimage. The Drexel Route launched from Indianapolis last May, and I was determined to squeeze in as much coverage as possible before my flight home. One more stop. One more moment. One more opportunity to see what Grace might reveal.

I followed the pilgrims into Illinois that first afternoon. They were headed to the Diocese of Joliet, where the local bishop would receive the Blessed Sacrament and lead adoration. The stop was in Paxton: a small town, a modest church, a moment that would make getting back to the airport uncomfortably tight. Missing my flight was a real possibility.

I went anyway.

At the time, it felt like instinct. Habit, really. I’ve learned over the years that the margins often hold the most interesting moments. What I didn’t know then was that I was about to photograph a man whose path would soon lead to one of the most consequential episcopal sees in the world, my hometown, New York.

That afternoon, Bishop Hicks received the Blessed Sacrament and the pilgrims with a quiet reverence that didn’t announce itself, and didn’t need to. He led the faithful prayerfully, humbly, as though nothing in the world mattered more than the Blessed Sacrament before him and the people gathered around him.

There was no sense of performance. No sense of ambition.

Only joy. Peace. Presence.

I didn’t “meet” him in the conventional sense. As my wife often jokes, I photograph a great many people, so whether that counts as “meeting” them is an open question. But I did observe him closely. And what I witnessed was a shepherd entirely at ease doing the most essential work of a bishop: leading souls toward Christ.

He moved easily among the pilgrims. He listened. He smiled. He prayed. He knelt before the Blessed Sacrament with the kind of reverence that doesn’t draw attention to itself, yet leaves an impression all the same. It was the posture of a man who knows where authority truly comes from.

Only later did the significance of that moment give pause.

When it was announced that Bishop Hicks would be installed as the next Archbishop of New York, my mind immediately returned to that afternoon in Paxton. To the near-miss. To the decision to go anyway. To the Grace of a moment I nearly skipped.

New York is not an easy place to shepherd a flock.

It is, in many ways, the cultural capital of the world, a city where countless cultures, languages, and lives converge within a few square miles. St. Patrick’s Cathedral is often called “America’s Parish Church,” a place that speaks to the entire nation even as it serves its own.

It is also a place with a remarkable legacy of leadership.

For all its challenges, and there are many, New York has been blessed, time and again, with exceptional archbishops. Men who led with courage, clarity, and faith through eras of profound change. The shoes Archbishop Hicks now steps into are well worn, and heavy.

And yet, if history has taught us anything, it’s this: the Church is not sustained by personalities alone.

If Archbishop Hicks proves equal to the task ahead, and there is every reason to believe he will, it will not be because of personal charisma or administrative skill alone.

It will be because of Grace.

Because the same Holy Spirit who guided him to a small church in Paxton is now leading him into the heart of one of the world’s most complex cities.

Looking back, I now understand why that extra stop mattered, and am yet again staggered by the gift it was.

The Holy Spirit, it seems, delights in reminding us that our finite wisdom rarely sees the full picture.

We show up. We follow where we’re led. And only later do we understand.

So as New York welcomes its new shepherd, amid the weight of history, the glare of cameras, and the hopes of two million Catholics, I find myself grateful for having seen him first in a quieter moment. Blessed Sacrament in hand. Pilgrims at his side. No hint of what was to come.

Because when the Holy Spirit is involved, you just never really know.

Welcome to New York, Your Excellency.

Read more about the installation in the National Catholic Register!

Thanks for reading! This is a truly independent, reader-supported periodical. Your support is crucial. If you are able, please consider a paid subscription or making a ‘Patron of the Arts’ donation of any amount. By doing so, you are not just supporting this effort; you’re a vital part of this mission.

You have my heartfelt thanks for your generosity and support, and please keep me in your prayers, and know of mine for each of you. God Bless, Jeff